Climbing on the branches of the family tree: The hands of Ardipithecus ramidus

As everyone has already heard by now, the long-awaited Ardipithecus ramidus has finally been published, and boy is she a beauty!  So many “anatomical surprises”! There are so many strange and new things about this skeleton that it took an entire issue of Science to describe them.  Clearly then, it will take a few blog posts.  The first post will be about the hands.  Feet will be next, and we’ll move on from there.

But first, a few basics.  The papers report on over 35 individuals represented by various parts of the body.  Lots of teeth.  They were found in Aramis, Ethiopia and date to 4.4 million years ago.  For reasons that I’ll discuss below later, we think that Ardi was a facultative biped who spent most of her time in the trees.  When she was up there, she walked above the branches with her palms and plantar surfaces in contact with the branch.

That Ardi is a palmigrade, above-the-branch walker is surprising. Based on the apes that we have around today (chimps, humans, gorillas, and orangs), most anthropologists have always constructed the common ancestor to chimps and humans as an animal who was suspensory when in the trees (that is, hanging from the branches), and a kunckle-walker when on the ground.  There have been plenty of people who have called this scenario into question (in fact, I talked about one of them here a few weeks ago), but that hasn’t stopped many anthropologists from using the chimp as an analog for what the last common ancestor roughly looked and acted like.  Ardi shows us that the LCA probably looked nothing like either the chimpanzee or the human, but was more likely a generalized Miocene ape which lacked the specializations of either.

(As an aside, I’ve seen a rather questionable quote by Owen Lovejoy mentioned a few times– something like, “Humans didn’t evolve from apes.”  It is a very unfortunate thing for him to have said from the standpoint of science journalism, but taken in the context of the 11 articles that he and the rest of the team have written, as well as numerous other quotations, he clearly means that humans didn’t evolve from anything that looks like any of the extant apes.)

Anyway, on to some anatomy!

Because the extant African apes are knuckle-walkers, they have stiff, inflexible hands and wrists that allow them to support their body weight in sort of a weird position.  Because they also have to climb trees for food and protection, their hands are very long and powerful.  Humans, on the other hand, have pretty mobile hands and wrists which allows us what we call a “power grip.” We are very good graspers, and this has allowed us to become the dextrous tool-wielders that we are.  Because of our close genetic similarity to chimps, and the close morphological similarity between chimps and gorillas, it has been argued that certain features of the Australopithecine wrist- and even the human wrist- were “hold overs” from the period of time when we, too were knuckle-walkers who required a stiff wrist and hand.

Ardi's hand. The inset includes the capitate from a chimpanzee, Ardipithecus, and a human.

However, Ardi’s hand more closely approximates the human hand than the knuckle-walker hand.  It is very flexible.  The midcarpal joint in particular is striking in its flexibility.  Ardi could lay her palms flat on the tree branch and support her entire weight this way.  In this respect, Ardi resembles many generalized Miocene apes, such as Proconsul. Because this wrist is so generalized and resembles the wrist of so many other Miocene apes, it is probably the ancestral condition.

If we look at it that way, then human hands are only moderately derived when compared to those of chimps and gorillas.  Humans don’t enjoy quite the degree of flexibility at the midcarpal joint that Ardi does, and we’ve enlarged our thumbs and shortened our fingers a little.  Chimps and gorillas both had to modify their hands substantially to be able to move around the way that they do.

[Edited to insert link and fix a typo]

Lovejoy, CO., Simpson, S., White, T., Asfaw, B., & Suwa, G. (2009). Careful Climbing in the Miocene: The Forelimbs of Ardipithecus ramidus and Humans Are Primitive Science, 326 (5949), 70-70 DOI: 10.1126/science.1175827